The Fionavar Tapestry Trilogy, Guy Gavriel Kay

I’m on vacation though October 25, so for the next few posts, I’ll be sharing brief reviews of some of my favorite books.

I have to admit that I have never in my life convinced anyone to read these books. I was in maybe the seventh or eighth grade when I read them for the first time, and I had very few friends at the time who were interested in fantasy. Even the ones who were wouldn’t consent to try them though. To this day, I have no idea why, but I’m still holding a grudge…in fact, I’m pretty sure this could be my super villain origin story. It would unfold with a scene where I’m sitting in front of my bookcase lovingly stroking the tattered covers of some of my favorite books, and all of a sudden, I try to rip them to shreds, fueled by the rage of the perpetually ignored. (I say “try,” because, really, have you ever tried to rip a book apart? It’s ridiculously difficult.) I’m not sure what kind of revenge I could possibly seek for an offense such as this; most likely, the evil version of me would just feel instant regret for destroying books and the rest of the story would be about me trying to repair them, wracked with guilt. Which is one reason why I would make a terrible nemesis.

Nevertheless, I’m still sad that I seem to be the only person on the planet to have read this trilogy (The Summer Tree, The Wandering Fire, and The Darkest Road). The story was so…forlorn. These were some of the first books I read that defined “angst” for me, and although now I don’t go in for such things (much), I still vividly remember the hold that story had over my innocent young heart. There are certain sections that are just worn away from me paging through them again and again. The characters were so quirky and flawed and lovable, and it all took place in one of my favorite fantasy realms.

Many years after I first found these books, I learned that Kay was recruited  by JRR Tolkien’s son to help edit The Silmarillion. Kay has attributed his success in large part to that experience – to the opportunity to glean so much from one of the best fantasy writers of all times. If I’d known that years ago, maybe I would have had more luck selling his books to my friends. I don’t know. I’m not personally a big fan of Tolkien’s work (the only novel of his I truly enjoyed was The Hobbit), so it might have prejudiced me against Kay myself had I known (I can be a little quirky when it comes to that sort of thing). I do, however, agree that having such an incredible opportunity as a young man shaped him as a writer.

Even though I don’t love Tolkien’s work, he is indisputably one of the greatest fantasy writers of all time, and I can see his influence on Kay’s style. The story he tells in these three books is fascinating and heartbreaking – a precursor, for my heart at least, to the books I love by Lev Grossman, The Magicians and The Magician King. Although Grossman’s style is much more modern than Kay’s, like Tolkien, they channel the emotional resonance that exists as the foundation of the very best books this genre has to offer.

To learn more about Guy Gavriel Kay, go here.

9 thoughts on “The Fionavar Tapestry Trilogy, Guy Gavriel Kay

    1. It’s funny that on this vacation I’m visiting one of the friends who tried these books and didn’t enjoy them, and we got into a discussion where she finally explained to me why she didn’t like them. I could feel my super villain powers deflating even further as I understood her point of view…damned empathy!

  1. Your post completely resonated with me. The Fionavar Tapestry still holds very fond memories for me after many years. It was one of the earliest fantasy stories I read as a child and, not that I think this was ever in question, firmly drew me into the fantasy genre. For me it remains, along with Le Guin’s Earthsea Trilogy, one of the most underrated series in the genre.

    And I continue to be impressed by everything I’ve read by Kay since!

    1. I agree! It has been ages since I read the Earthsea Trilogy, but I love LeGuin, and having read both trilogies around the same time when I was a kid, they will always remain belovedly intertwined in my literary memory!

  2. You’ve sold ’em to me! Although if you were reading them in junior high, they might be young-adultish (I’m guessing?), I think they might have to go onto my TBR list. It’s a long one, granted, and I have review posts stacked up to write all the way through next June or so, but I can never turn down a good fantasy novel, so I’ll get there eventually!

    1. They actually are straight fantasy – not YA – just something I found in my library after I’d finished reading all the YA books they had (it wasn’t a big collection). I hope you enjoy them as much as I do!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s