Silver Moon, Catherine Lundoff

I have a confession to make, and I hope it won’t make you think less of me. Not every book I enjoy is the world’s most profound read. For some of you (and I know who you are – you are the readers who, like me, were profoundly grateful at the invention of the Kindle because it meant you could henceforth pretend to be reading great literature while actually devouring blush-inducing fantasy novels intended for fifteen year olds), this is not only an obvious statement of fact but also completely acceptable. Maybe you’re a speed reader like me (yes, I’m entitled to have one thing that sets me apart from the masses, and since it is definitely not running, cooking, activism, math comprehension, yoga head stands, wealth, wearing heels, charisma, etc, I will hold up my ability to skim and comprehend with pride!), in which case, you can afford to “waste your time” (gag) on books slower readers deem unworthy.

I suspect this is the case for the vast majority of readers; my husband is a slower reader, and while he gleefully pages through books like Cannery Row and Don Quixote (novels he considers worth the effort exerted), I jump from one book to the next like a man in lost in the desert – a constant flow of words, high quality or low, is what keeps me alive. For those of you who don’t fall into one of those two categories, there is a third, one I call “the powerful sense of self reader” – you are so comfortable in your own skin that regardless of how quickly you read, you feel no pressure whatsoever to care what anyone thinks of your choices. In the long list of things I’m not good at, being comfortable in my own skin is right up there, so while I know such readers exist (and annoyingly, am friends with quite of few of them), I can only envy them from afar. They probably need no excuse to review a book about menopausal women who turn into werewolves, but alas, I feel some justification is called for.

The other night, while my better half and I were curled up reading, he innocently asked, “What book are you finishing up now?” Since the books I’m reviewing are rarely ones he’s familiar with, my response always includes the title (in this case, Silver Moon) with a brief description guaranteed to get a rise out of him (it’s about menopausal women who turn into werewolves!). He stared at me blankly for a moment before saying, “well, my book has Islamic jihadists, Chinese hackers, British spies, unhinged Russian mobsters, special op soldiers, prolific fantasy writers, and an autistic snowboarder.” That’s great honey! But did you hear me?! Menopausal werewolves. When you’re making a list of things that scare me, add the word “menopausal” to any of them, and immediately you take terror to the next level. He really didn’t have much of an argument for that, but I could almost see his brain calculating how this conversation might come back to haunt him in twenty years.

So yes, Silver Moon is an unabashed look at menopausal werewolves, and I’ll be honest, I read it in large part because I thought it was an idea my mother would really get a kick out of. Overall though, I ended up enjoying the concept of the story. The idea of older women becoming werewolves, as well as the more common story-telling subject of teenage boys changing, are both wholly appropriate from a biological perspective. For men, the most significant physical changes occur during adolescence, and while that’s certainly the case for women, we also have an extra-special bonus change later in life, and in some ways, that second change feels even more significant (probably because it is often accompanied by the delightful twin side effects of grief and a feeling of cultural obsolescence).

I love the ideas that Lundoff embraces, of older women being venerated, of being the powerful protectors, of being a long way from death, though I’m not completely crazy about her style. It was a little jumpy for me to fully sink into the story, which I wanted to because it was quick-paced and funny. She creates characters that could have more stories in them, and a town that is split between believing in ancient magic and turning a blind eye to the chaos it creates. Sure, those of you working your way through the list of the 100 Greatest Fiction Books of All Times (I personally know three people doing this right now, and I swear I love them even so!) may not have time for menopausal werewolves, but for the rest of us? Hey, it’s summer! If ever there were a time to dabble in the supernatural, it’s during these long, hot June nights (which I can only imagine simulate, quite effectively, the hell that is hot flashes).

To find out more about Catherine Lundoff, pop over here.

11 thoughts on “Silver Moon, Catherine Lundoff

    1. I heartily agree. I’ve been actively trying to take time off from guilty pleasure books this year (or at least enough to give other books a fair shot at my time!), but sometimes, you just have to give in and enjoy the mental vacation!

  1. The thing is that when you are Lundoff-werewolf-age-appropriate, that is the same era when you become a comfortable in your own skin reader … I speak from personal authority … so bring it on.

    1. When you read this book, you will have no choice but agree with me that it definitely feels like a novel you would have written (and since I’m the only person who has read the ones you have, I can say that with the utmost authority and glee!)

  2. Ha ha! I love that. I have to do book reviews for my job and have to read books I wouldn’t choose to read otherwise. SoI have a few guilty reads as well which are a sheer joy to enjoy.My guilt lies in threading the occasional fluffy English village story. Bliss! But menopausal werewolves haven’t yet lured me into their paths. But that’s not saying it won’t happen.

  3. Nice post. A lot of the things you said ring true to me. I put off reading the Twilight books for ages because of all the hate they were receiving, but when I read them all in a few days (I think I have your skim skills), I actually enjoyed the story. So what that they are aimed at teenage girls, so what that they don’t have huge morals and underlying themes etc. I enjoyed them, so I don’t care now what other people say. From now on, I’m going to read what I want and not care that it doesn’t come under the ‘highly intelligent read’ category. I’m probably not intelligent enough to read all those anyway. I think it’s great that people are reading anything, at least we all won’t turn into couch potato zombies :)

    1. Hear hear! I often feel the same about books considered to be high literature – it’s not that I don’t like them or that I can’t understand them, but sometimes I just don’t care! I love to read for the pleasure of it – not necessarily as a mark of some great intellectual achievement. And better that we read some silly books than no books at all!

      1. Exactly. No offense, but some of these books which are apparently ‘high literature’ sound so boring to me. Enjoyment should totally come first, after all, that’s the whole point of reading, isn’t it?

    1. It’s not the best of the best, as far as books I’ve read go, but it just was so silly, and it was clear she had so much fun writing it that it was hard not to be won over!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s